There are multiple ways that a list like this can be compiled; by order as listed in the Scott Specialized Catalog (Type I,Ia,Ib,Ic,II,III,IIIa,IV), by order of issue, by a process of elimination based on unique design characteristics or in the order that a collector or dealer is likely to acquire them, from the most common to the rarest (Based on Scott “VF” catalog value). For this article, we will use the last method.
1. TYPE IV (Scott #9) is defined by the fact that the outer curved frame lines at the top and/or bottom are recut. There are 7 different possible recuts;
Tip – Recut lines are much heavier than the normal curved frame lines , so look for that feature. Compare Type IV with Type II, which has normal curved frame lines.
2. TYPE II (Scott #7) is defined by having complete curved frame lines at top and bottom but with parts of the bottom outer designs missing (incomplete).
Tip – compare to Type I, which has complete design or to Type IV, which has the curved frame line(s) recut.
3. TYPE IIIa (Scott 8A) is defined by having the curved frame line above “U.S. Postage” OR below “One Cent” broken (but both are not broken);
Tip – If either the top or bottom portions of the design are cut off by poor separation such that the defining characteristic cannot be clearly seen, then the only way to positively identify this type (III a) as well as several other types that may have the defining parts missing, is by original plating (whereby the stamps is located to the exact position on the plate).
4. TYPE III (Scott #8) has the curved frame lines at top AND bottom broken (note that Tip given for Type IIIa also applies to Type III);
5. TYPE Ic (Scott 6b) has partly cut away top, bottom left plume is complete (or nearly complete), bottom right plume and tiny ball ornaments are incomplete.
Tip – All of the different type I designs are difficult to identify, so careful examination is necessary. Eliminate the other more common Types so that you can safely conclude your copy is a type I variation.
6. Type Ib (Scott #5A) has complete top and nearly complete bottom, but the plume-like scrolls at bottom and balls below bottom label not as clear as Type I (which is totally complete on all four sides)
8. Type I (Scott #5); is complete on all four sides except very slightly incomplete at top. This type only occurs on one position on the right pane of Plate 1 Early (Position 7R1E). It is an extremely valuable stamp used or unused and the likelihood of you ever encountering this stamp are very slim, but it of course is included in the correct place on this list
And briefly listing these in Scott order is as follows;
Type I Scott #5, complete design;
Type 1b Scott #5A, complete at top but not fully complete at bottom, though nearly so;
Type Ia Scott #6, complete at bottom but top slightly cut away;
Type Ic Scott 6b, same as Type Ia but bottom rigbt plume not complete, bottom left is complete;
Type II Scott #7, complete at top, but not at bottom and missing more parts of design than Ty.Ib,Ic;
Type III Scott #8, curved frame lines at top ad bottom are both broken;
Type IIIa Scott #8A, top or bottom curved line broken, but not both;
Type IV Scott #9, top and/or bottom curved lines recut.
Designs of the U.S. Regular Issues of 1851-1860
Postage Stamps of the United States - 1851